BigCommerce vs. Adobe Commerce (Formerly Magento)

Break up with your platform.

What once felt powerful now feels like overhead: more cost, more maintenance, and more to manage. Leave complexity behind and grow faster, with up to 60% lower total cost.

No pressure. No commitment.

Mock text conversation framing Adobe Magento platform upgrades and rising fees as a dramatic relationship breakup.

Backed by brands who know the difference.

Yeti Cycles
Saddleback Leather
Discount Pool Supply
TradeTools
Coco Republic
ToolSaver

The Real Deal

Build forward, not back.

If you’re rebuilding for ACCS, you’re making a fresh start. Choose a platform that helps you launch faster, scale easier, and spend less time fixing things behind the scenes.

Isometric graphic of the BigCommerce logo layered over multi-storefront and omnichannel technical features.

More extensions shouldn’t mean more expenses.

Every add-on comes with a price, and it adds up quickly. Get features included from the start, so costs stay predictable as you grow.

Saying “we’ll need a developer for that” gets old.

Every change, update, or new idea gets stuck behind a dev ticket. Move at a speed that’s better for your business.

From Magento to momentum.

Saddleback Leather didn't overhaul their brand — they overhauled their platform. The result? A 43% increase in revenue and a team that finally stopped fighting their tech stack. Watch how they made the switch.

Expand to new markets without complexity.

Simplify growth, improve conversion, test and expand to new markets without pesky bottlenecks getting in the way.

Sleep better knowing your platform’s covered.

Keeping up with vulnerabilities, compliance, and threats isn’t exactly relaxing. With enterprise-grade security built in, you’ll get the best rest of your life.

See the difference.

211%

ROI within 8 months.

90%

developer time savings.

30%

increase in conversion.

More capabilities, less complication.

We’re not saying it’s a bad relationship, but it might be worth a closer look. Weigh your options to see how your current platform stacks up.

Category

Adobe Commerce (Formerly Magento)

BigCommerce

Launch to Market Time

Months to 12+ months (Extensive build).

Weeks to 2–4 months (Rapid deployment).

Total Cost of Ownership (TCO)

High, variable costs (~50K–200K+ over 3 years).

Predictable ecommerce costs* (~5K–30K over 3 years.)

Maintenance & Upgrades

Manual (Requires manual patching and version upgrades).

Low maintenance ecommerce platform (Automatic updates).

Standard Features (Includes B2B)

Custom setup (Requires expensive extensions or Adobe B2B suite).

Native out-of-the-box (Built-in B2B quote management*, multi-storefront, and fully customizable).

Developer Dependency

High (Requires dedicated Adobe Commerce developers).

Minimal (Intuitive for marketing teams).

Scalability & Performance

Manual tuning (Depends heavily on hosting setup).

Scalability without complexity (Auto-scaling, built-in Fastly CDN).

Security & PCI Compliance

Merchant-managed (Shared responsibility; manual patching).

Native & managed (Built-in PCI DSS Level 1).

SEO Capabilities

Extension-dependent (Requires expert developer tuning).

Optimized Core Web Vitals out-of-the-box. Built-in 301 redirects + URL preservation.

Ecosystem & Integrations

Massive but complex (Extensions require extensive dev testing).

Native integrations (Connects natively to tools like NetSuite, QuickBooks, and ShipStation).

Multi-Storefront

Extension/setup needed. Multi-site support.

Built-in features for international expansion.

*This number reflects our smallest tier of pricing plans, however for mid-market enterprises, this cost can scale up to ~$50K–$150K+ over 3 years. B2B Quote Management has to be installed and incurs an additional cost.

Where growing businesses go after Adobe Commerce.

This is what scaling feels like when your platform finally stops getting in the way.

Blue check mark

211% ROI within 8 months.

Blue check mark

90% developer time savings.

Blue check mark

30% increase in site conversion.

Ready to make it official?

Make things less complicated and move to a platform built to grow with you.

Switching from Adobe Commerce (Formerly Magento) to BigCommerce FAQs

The biggest difference comes down to how much you want to manage: BigCommerce is an open platform, which means hosting, security, updates, and core functionality are all built in and handled for you, without sacrificing the flexibility to customize.



Adobe Commerce (Magento), on the other hand, offers deep customization but requires you to manage infrastructure, security, and ongoing maintenance. For most small to mid-sized businesses, that means more time spent running the platform instead of growing the business.

BigCommerce offers predictable subscription pricing that includes hosting, security, and many built-in features, making it easier to budget as you grow.



Adobe Commerce often starts with licensing fees and quickly adds costs for hosting, developers, extensions, and upgrades.



For many mid-market brands, total costs can exceed $100K annually. That’s why businesses that switch to BigCommerce commonly see 40–60% lower total cost of ownership.



Migrating from Adobe Commerce to BigCommerce is typically faster and more straightforward than expected, especially compared to rebuilding within the Adobe ecosystem. Most migrations for SMB and mid-market customers can be completed in weeks with the help of built-in tools, experienced partners, and proven migration frameworks.



If you’re already facing a rebuild for Adobe Commerce as a Cloud Service (ACCS), switching platforms often doesn’t add extra effort, it simply ensures you’re rebuilding on a better foundation.

BigCommerce is designed so marketers, operators, and business owners can manage the store without relying on developers for everyday tasks.



Adobe Commerce is powerful but more complex, often requiring technical expertise for updates, changes, and new features.



For growing teams, this can slow down execution and create bottlenecks, especially when every change depends on developer availability.

With BigCommerce, maintenance and security are handled automatically, including platform updates, hosting, and PCI compliance. This reduces risk and removes the need for constant monitoring.



Adobe Commerce requires businesses to manage their own hosting, apply security patches, and stay on top of vulnerabilities. Missing updates can introduce real security risks, which adds both operational pressure and potential cost.

Both platforms offer strong customization capabilities, but they approach it differently:



BigCommerce provides flexibility through APIs, headless architecture, and a large app ecosystem, allowing businesses to customize experiences without needing a developer for every change. This makes it easier to balance flexibility with speed.



Adobe Commerce enables deep customization through code, which often requires ongoing developer involvement.

BigCommerce is optimized for performance out of the box, with built-in infrastructure that scales automatically as your business grows.



Adobe Commerce performance depends heavily on how well your hosting and environment are configured, which typically requires developer oversight.



As a result, maintaining speed and reliability on Adobe Commerce (Formerly Magento) often becomes an ongoing technical effort rather than a built-in advantage.

Both platforms support strong SEO capabilities, but BigCommerce makes them easier to implement and maintain. It includes built-in tools for managing URLs, redirects, and site performance, which are key factors for search rankings.



Adobe Commerce offers flexibility, but often requires extensions or developer support to implement and maintain SEO best practices consistently.

BigCommerce includes native integrations with major channels like Amazon, eBay, Google, and social platforms, along with built-in support for multi-currency and multi-storefront. This makes it easier to expand into new markets without adding complexity.



Adobe Commerce can support these capabilities as well, but typically requires additional extensions and setup, which can increase both cost and effort.

BigCommerce offers B2B Edition, a dedicated B2B functionality, with features like price lists, customer groups, quoting, and buyer portals built in. This allows mid-market B2B businesses to launch and scale without heavy customization.



Adobe Commerce also has strong B2B capabilities, particularly for highly complex enterprise use cases, but often requires more setup and ongoing development to maintain.

BigCommerce is designed to scale by default. It’s a fully-hosted open platform with 99.99% uptime and infrastructure built to handle high-volume traffic and large catalogs, including 2M+ SKUs and 400+ API calls per second.



Adobe Commerce can scale as well, but it typically requires investment in hosting, performance tuning, and development resources. For growing businesses, this can make scaling feel more like a project than a natural progression.

Adobe Commerce is well-suited for teams with dedicated developers who want full control over every aspect of the platform.



BigCommerce, however, offers an API-first and headless-ready architecture that still allows for deep customization, but with less maintenance overhead.



This means developers can spend more time building differentiated experiences and less time managing infrastructure and updates.